Is Florida the worst state in the nation in mental health care, elder fraud, homeowner insurance rates and rent increases?
That’s what California Gov. Gavin Newsom said.
The Democratic governor has been highlighting Republican-governed states’ shortcomings in recent X posts and comments. In June, amid Los Angeles protests about ICE operations in the city, Newsom sparred with Republican governors over their states’ homicide rates. In July, he compared California’s federal contributions to those Texas makes.
Now he’s on to Florida, where he says directives from the Trump administration and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis to remove street markings that commemorate LGBTQ+ rights reflect misplaced priorities. The policies could affect rainbow-painted crossings across Florida, including St. Petersburg, West Palm Beach and Fort Lauderdale.
“Florida: #51 in mental health care, #1 in home insurance costs, #1 in elder fraud, #1 in rent hikes. But let’s crack down on… rainbow crosswalks. Totally the crisis,” Newsom wrote July 18 on X.
Newsom’s accuracy is mixed. Overall, analyses show that Florida lags in almost all of these areas, but they don’t consistently show the state running dead last in each.
No. 51 for mental health care?
Florida has long ranked low in this category. We found three reports that showed the state last or second-to-last on mental health care — one from 2025 and two based on data that is at least a decade old. But other rankings put it in a slightly better light.
Sign up for PolitiFact texts
A report published in April 2025 by Rehabs.com which used data from the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, said Florida spent the lowest amount per capita of any state on mental health — $36.05. By comparison, the state with the highest mental health expenditures, Maine, spent $362.75 per capita.
Mental Health America, a mental health and wellbeing nonprofit, ranked Florida 21st for mental health using 2024 data about overall mental illness prevalence and access to care. So, Florida is slightly better than half the nation by that measure.
In a May 2023 report, the Florida Hospital Association ranked Florida 46th in the nation for mental health care access, making it one of the worst states. The measure includes access to health insurance, treatment, quality and cost of insurance, access to special education and mental health workforce availability.
In January, Forbes ranked Florida as the fourth-worst state for mental health care access, finding that people in the state with mental illness lack access to care because of its high health care costs and mental health treatment center shortages.
Newsom’s office pointed PolitiFact to a 2020 state grand jury report that studied school safety following the deadly 2018 mass shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Florida, by a shooter who had been treated for mental health issues. The report described Florida’s mental health system as disjointed and underfunded, and said it provided less money per capita than any other state, citing a graph from a 2016 National Association of State Mental Health Program Directors Research Institute report.
“Although this graph has been composed from financial information from the 2015 fiscal year,” the grand jury wrote in a footnote, “Florida is still the lowest-ranked state in terms of mental health care and treatment spending as of 2019-20, and we see no reason why that status quo would not continue into the foreseeable future absent intervention by the Legislature and the Governor.” The group did not provide further citations on Florida’s ranking.
Newsom also pointed to 2017 PolitiFact coverage evaluating the association’s finding that ranked Florida 51 out of 52 jurisdictions (it includes Washington, D.C., and Puerto Rico) in state mental health spending. This ranking is also outdated, based on fiscal year 2014 data.
No. 1 state for home insurance costs?
Newsom has a point that Florida often is on the high end of home insurance costs — much like his own state — because of its exposure to natural disasters including hurricanes.
But is it the most expensive now? Rankings are all over the map. Some put Florida at the tippy-top, while others show it’s high, but not highest.
Newsom’s office shared reports that said Florida averaged the highest home insurance premiums, as well as a September 2024 U.S. Census Bureau report that said Florida had 1.2 million homeowners paying $4,000 a year or more for homeowner’s insurance, the highest share of any state.
According to the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, the average 2024 statewide premium is $3,731, based on policies written for all levels of coverage across Florida’s 67 counties.
Consumer websites, however, vary on the amount Florida homeowners pay on average for insurance because of their different methodologies.
Bankrate, a consumer financial services website, ranked Florida third-highest in home insurance costs, estimating that homeowners pay $5,695 annually to cover a $300,000 home. Nebraska came in first at $6,425 and Louisiana second at $6,185.
Insurify, an insurance comparison shopping website, said Florida homeowners paid the most for insurance in 2024, with an average yearly rate of $14,140.
These numbers vary for a few reasons, insurance industry experts said. Some analyzed one specific level of coverage. Some included higher coverage amounts and additional types of coverage such as flood and disaster insurance. Others took averages from a handful of zip codes.
There is no definitive source comparing home insurance rates across states because “every consumer quoting site determines premium averages differently,” Mark Friedlander, senior director of media relations at the industry-funded Insurance Information Institute, said.
Experts said data based on the average of actual premiums policyholders paid presents a more accurate picture.
Lending Tree, an online lending marketplace, did this in a June report using data from S&P Global Market Intelligence, which captures data directly from each Department of Insurance across the country. The report ranked Florida ninth highest in average premiums while finding it had the nation’s lowest average one-year premium increase in 2024.
No. 1 for elder fraud?
Long a destination for retirees, Florida has one of the nation’s largest populations of people over 60. So, it makes sense that the state would be a leader in fraud reports by that group.
Fraud often leads to the loss of money or some other harm, and scammers often target older people.
Florida ranked second in the raw number of fraud reports filed by people over 60, according to the FBI’s 2023 and 2024 crime reports.
It trailed Newsom’s California both times.
The FBI didn’t calculate states’ per capita rankings, but All About Cookies, a digital security research organization, used the FBI data and Census Bureau statistics to calculate states’ elderly fraud complaints per capita. That organization found that Arizona had the most elderly fraud complaints per capita in 2023, while Florida landed in 12th place.
That may not be unexpected; California has the nation’s highest population of residents 65 and older, followed by Texas and Florida.
California also ranked first in both 2023 and 2024 for financial losses from fraud complaints by seniors; Florida ranked second in 2023 and third behind California and Texas in 2024.
Although Florida did not take the top spot on this metric, fraud is a problem statewide across all populations.
Newsom’s office pointed us to a 2024 report by the Federal Trade Commission, an independent U.S. agency focused on consumer protection, that listed Florida as first in the most fraud reports per capita. But that included all age groups and was not specific to people over 60. His office also shared a 2019 news story based on similar FTC data from 2017 showing the same ranking.
No. 1 for rent hikes?
Florida has high rent compared with the national average, especially in cities such as Miami and Tampa. But we found no current ranking that put the state as the highest in the nation for rent increases.
Florida largely prohibits cities and counties from implementing rent stabilization or control policies, making it easier for landlords to increase rents.
Construction Coverage, a nonpartisan organization that specializes in research about real estate and construction, reported that from 2024 to mid-2025, Florida’s median rent increased 6.4% — the 15th highest median increase in the country. Montana had the highest hike, with a 20.7% increase in median rent.
Newsom’s office cited a 2023 report by Benzinga, a data technology and investment platform, that said from March 2020 to March 2023, Florida’s rent increased by 45.77%, the most of all states. Other news outlets also reported the number.
Rents increased nationally during and after the COVID-19 pandemic because of a combination of higher demand and lower rental availability. However, since 2024, rental prices in Florida have started to stabilize.
In 2025, SmartAsset, a financial advising company, included some Florida cities, such as St. Petersburg, among areas with the highest rent increases from February 2024 to February 2025. But none ranked first in the category.
House Beautiful, a real estate magazine, concluded from Realtor.com data that Miami and the Tampa area have experienced the highest increases in average rent among major cities since 2019.
Starting in 2024, Benzinga began reporting decreases in rents across Florida. Other reports also found that many areas of Florida have experienced rent decreases since 2024.
Our ruling
Newsom said Florida is “#51 in mental health care, #1 in home insurance costs, #1 in elder fraud, #1 in rent hikes.”
Florida lags other states on all these metrics, but the rankings vary.
On mental health care, rankings we found placed the state at or near the bottom of the nation.
On home insurance costs, some analyses show Florida expenses as the nation’s highest, while others show it in third- or ninth-place.
One metric showed Florida had the highest fraud complaints per capita across all populations. But when looking specifically at raw numbers of complaints by people over 60, California and Texas beat out Florida, depending on the year.
And high rent is a trouble spot for Florida, too. From 2020 to early 2023, Florida’s median rent increased more than in any other state, one analysis showed. But in a more recent report focused on 2024 to mid-2025, it came in 15th. Rents in Florida have also begun to slightly decrease since 2024.
The statement is partially accurate but leaves out important details or takes things out of context. We rate it Half True.
